Builder's Risk vs General Liability — What's the Difference?

Builder's risk insurance covers physical damage to the structure and materials while you build. General liability covers claims from other people, such as an injury to a visitor or damage to a neighbor's property. Neither replaces the other, and most construction projects need both.

The core difference

Builder's risk insurance covers physical damage to the structure and materials during construction, while general liability covers third-party injury and property damage claims tied to the work [1]. General liability does not cover damage to the structure being built, and builder's risk does not cover third-party injury or property damage claims, so most projects need both [2]. A short way to say it: builder's risk insures the project, and general liability insures everyone around it [3].

Builder's riskGeneral liability
ProtectsThe building under construction and materials [1]Other people and their property [1]
ExampleFire, theft, or vandalism of materials and the structure [4]A visitor is injured on site, or the work damages a neighbor's property [1]
Typical holderWhoever has a financial stake: owner, general contractor, sometimes the lender [5]The contractor; contractors are normally required to carry it [4]

Who buys builder's risk

It is either provided by the general contractor or by the property owner. Review the construction contract to see who is responsible [6]. Your builder will likely have general liability, but it is not always their responsibility to buy the builder's risk policy as well [6]. Anyone with a financial interest in the project can be named on the policy, including the property owner, lenders, architects, and the general contractor [5].

If you are the owner-builder

You will probably need builder's risk. If you own the building under construction, lenders might require a type of builder's risk sometimes called owner-builder construction insurance [7].

What neither one covers

Builder's risk generally does not cover personal liability, personal property, flood, or earthquake [5]. It does not protect the employees on the site [8], which is a separate coverage called workers' compensation. Builder's risk is also only in effect while the construction is going on: homeowners insurance is for completed homes, and builder's risk is for homes still under construction [5]. Builder's risk is also sold as course of construction insurance, which is the same product under another name [9].

Practical steps

Ask who is buying builder's risk before you sign the contract, make sure your lender is named on the policy if required, and confirm that general liability certificates from every contractor are current.

Sources

  1. Hub International, "Builder's risk vs. general liability" (Canada page): https://www.hubinternational.com/en-ca/faqs/construction/builders-risk-vs-general-liability/
  2. Hub International, "Builder's risk vs. general liability": https://www.hubinternational.com/en-us/faqs/construction/builders-risk-vs-general-liability/
  3. Alkeme Insurance, "Builders risk vs. general liability": https://alkemeins.com/blog/builders-risk-vs-general-liability
  4. The Motley Fool, "Builder's risk insurance": https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/insurance/homeowners/builders-risk-insurance/
  5. Insurance.com, "Building a house": https://insurance.com/home-and-renters-insurance/home-insurance-basics/building-a-house.html
  6. Policygenius, "Builders risk insurance for homeowners": https://www.policygenius.com/homeowners-insurance/builders-risk-insurance-for-homeowners/
  7. Progressive Commercial, "Builders risk vs. general liability": https://www.progressivecommercial.com/business-resources/builders-risk-vs-general-liability/
  8. The Hartford, "Builders risk vs. general liability": https://www.thehartford.com/general-liability-insurance/builders-risk-vs-general-liability
  9. The Motley Fool, "Builder's risk insurance" (course of construction): https://www.fool.com/money/insurance/homeowners/builders-risk-insurance

Key facts

  • Builder's risk covers the structure and materials during construction.
  • General liability covers third-party injury and property damage claims.
  • Neither policy replaces the other, so most projects need both.
  • Either the owner or the general contractor may buy builder's risk, so check the contract.
  • Builder's risk does not cover employee injuries, which fall under workers' compensation.

What lenders look at

A lender with money in an unfinished house wants it insured against fire, theft, and storm damage, which is what builder's risk does. That is why it is commonly required before closing, with the lender named on the policy. General liability and workers' compensation are usually requested for the builder as part of approving the contractor.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming the contractor's general liability policy also covers damage to the house.
  • Assuming the builder bought builder's risk without checking the contract.
  • Letting builder's risk lapse before the project is complete.
  • Not naming the lender on the policy when required.
  • Expecting builder's risk to cover flood, earthquake, or worker injuries.

When this typically happens

  • Before closing, when the lender requires proof of coverage.
  • Before work starts, when contractors submit insurance certificates.
  • At project completion, when builder's risk ends and homeowners insurance begins.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need both builder's risk and general liability?

Most construction projects do, because each covers a different exposure and neither replaces the other [2].

Who is supposed to buy builder's risk?

Either the general contractor or the property owner. Check your construction contract [6].

Does builder's risk cover someone getting hurt on site?

No. Third-party injury is general liability, and employee injuries are workers' compensation [1][8].

Is course of construction insurance different?

No. It is another name for builder's risk [9].

How OwnerDraw helps

OwnerDraw tracks insurance certificates and expiration dates for you and each subcontractor, so a lapse does not go unnoticed before a draw.

Related articles