Allowances Explained (and How They Blow Up Budgets)

An allowance is a placeholder dollar amount in a budget or contract for an item that has not been selected yet, such as flooring, tile, or light fixtures. If what you choose costs more than the allowance, you pay the difference. Allowances blow up budgets when they are set too low, vaguely defined, or left unselected until late.

What an allowance is

A construction allowance is a dollar amount included as the estimated cost for items not finalized when the contract is signed [1]. It is a budget placeholder for items not yet selected or fully specified [2]. Most allowances cover material selections that have not been made yet, such as fixtures and finishes [1].

Two types

There are generally two types: material allowances and installation allowances [3][4]. A material allowance covers only the cost of the materials, not the labor to unload, install, or finish them [4]. An installation allowance applies when work cannot be fully quantified before starting [4].

An example

Suppose a budget has an $8,000 tile allowance, and it covers materials only:

ScenarioTile selectedResult
Over the allowance$11,000$3,000 overage, paid by you
Under the allowance$6,500$1,500 underage, which should be credited back

Allowances should be negotiated before work begins. A key issue is how to account for an overage or underage, and both should be credited so both parties are treated fairly [5]. In this example, installation labor would be a separate cost, since the allowance covers materials only.

How allowances blow up budgets

  • Set too low. Builders can keep allowances low to make a bid look more economical until the contract is signed [6]. A low allowance is not savings, only a number that will rise later. Add realistic prices based on current market conditions [5].
  • Vague scope. If the allowance does not say what it covers, disputes follow. Include specific descriptions of what the allowance covers and clarify how overages and underages will be reconciled [5].
  • Late selections. Unresolved allowances can affect the schedule and can even require changes to work already completed [7]. Document selection deadlines in the contract [5].
  • Too many. The more allowances, the more opportunities for misunderstandings [5]. One way to limit them is to make more of your selections before you start [8].

Protecting yourself

Ask for notice of overages ahead of time, so you can decide before the money is spent [9]. Compare allowances against actual current prices, and track each allowance as its own line so the running total stays visible.

Sources

  1. How to Use Allowances in Residential Construction: https://seal-trout-d665.squarespace.com/blog/how-to-use-allowances-in-residential-construction
  2. UpCounsel, "Understanding construction allowance in contracts": https://proxy-production.upcounsel.com/construction-contract-allowances
  3. Levelset, "Construction allowances": https://www.levelset.com/?p=45227
  4. Buildern, "Construction allowances explained": https://buildern.com/resources/blog/construction-allowances/
  5. UpCounsel, "Construction contract allowances": https://upcounsel.com/construction-contract-allowances
  6. Houzz discussion, "New construction allowances": https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5803522/
  7. Pro Remodeler, "The lowdown on calculated allowances": https://proremodeler.com/lowdown-calculated-allowances
  8. The Motley Fool, "3 things to know about allowances in a new build": https://www.fool.com/the-ascent/mortgages/articles/3-things-to-know-about-allowances-in-a-new-build/
  9. Building Advisor, "Allowances in construction contracts": https://buildingadvisor.com/project-management/contracts/red-flag-clauses/allowances-in-construction-contracts/

Key facts

  • An allowance is a placeholder amount for an item that has not been selected when the budget or contract is made.
  • Allowances are either material allowances or installation allowances.
  • If your selection costs more than the allowance, you pay the overage; if it costs less, it should be credited.
  • Low, vague, or late-resolved allowances are a leading cause of budget overruns.
  • Fewer allowances means fewer surprises, so make selections early.

What lenders look at

Lenders review the budget against the contract and the plans. Unrealistic allowances make the budget look weak, because the total is likely to grow when selections are made. A budget with realistic allowances, clear scopes, and selection dates is easier to approve and easier to draw against.

Common mistakes

  • Accepting low allowances because they make the total look smaller.
  • Not asking what the allowance covers, such as materials only or materials plus installation.
  • Putting off selections until the schedule is already waiting on them.
  • Not tracking overages as they happen.
  • Treating an allowance as a spending target rather than a placeholder estimate.

When this typically happens

  • When the contract and budget are prepared, before selections are made.
  • During design and selection, as choices are priced against allowances.
  • At each draw, as overages and underages are reconciled.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if I spend more than the allowance?

You pay the difference. The contract should state how overages are billed [5].

What if I spend less?

The underage should be credited so both parties are treated fairly [5].

Does an allowance include installation?

Not necessarily. A material allowance covers materials only, while an installation allowance covers work that cannot be fully quantified in advance [4].

How can I avoid allowance problems?

Use realistic prices, define what each covers, set selection deadlines, and make as many selections as you can before starting [5][8].

How OwnerDraw helps

OwnerDraw's Allowances & Selections tracking shows each allowance against what you actually choose, so you can see an overage coming before you commit.

Related articles